Updated Apr 6, 2026 • ~8 min read
Chapter 13: I Am the Boyfriend
Scarlett
Maya’s birthday party was at a wine bar in the Mission that had excellent charcuterie and the kind of ambient lighting designed to make everyone look like a better version of themselves, which was the only reason Scarlett had agreed to come. Six months pregnant and she was starting to feel like her silhouette belonged to a different story entirely — she loved Wren with a ferocity that surprised her daily, but she had not fully processed what it meant to exist in public as visibly, undeniably pregnant at a party where the average age was twenty-nine and the average conversation topic was promotion tracks.
Priya had come with her and stationed herself at Scarlett’s elbow with the protective efficiency of a very good bodyguard who also happened to have strong opinions about brie.
“You look incredible,” Priya said, because she was a good best friend.
“I look like I swallowed a melon.”
“A beautiful melon. The most glowing melon.”
“I will eat all the charcuterie and you will not stop me.”
“Would never dream of it.”
Declan had come separately — he was at a client thing first, texted her he’d be there by eight. It was seven forty-five and she was managing perfectly well on her own, which she was going to remind herself of continuously, because the fact that she kept checking her phone for his ETA was purely logistical.
She was checking it logistically.
She was at the charcuterie board, genuinely concentrating on the question of whether the aged gouda was better than the manchego, when she heard him.
“Scarlett.”
Her stomach dropped in an unrelated way to the pregnancy.
Chad Whitfield was standing six feet away, in the blazer she’d given him feedback on twice over the course of their two-year relationship — he’d never changed it, because Chad did not change things that weren’t his idea to change. He was taller than she remembered, or she was misremembering, or she was six months pregnant and standing next to a cheese board and he had the specific advantage of catching her by surprise.
“Chad,” she said, in the voice she used for professional situations.
His eyes moved to her stomach and then back up, and she watched him do the math with the specific transparency of a man who thought he was being inscrutable. She had dated him for two years and she knew every expression he had. This one was the one where he was recalibrating rapidly.
“You look —”
“Pregnant,” she supplied. “I am.”
“Right.” A pause. He recovered with the smoothness of someone who spent a lot of time in rooms where recovery was professionally important. “How far along?”
“Six months.”
“Six months,” he repeated, and she could see him calculating backward to a timeline that didn’t involve him, and watching him arrive at that timeline and then, somehow, past it — watching his expression do something she hadn’t anticipated. Not hurt. Not even surprised, really. Something more like: reconfiguration.
“Scarlett,” he said, and his voice had shifted into the one he used when he was about to say something he considered generous, “I think we should talk.”
“We’re talking.”
“I mean — privately.” He glanced around at the party. “I’ve been thinking. About us.”
She stared at him. “Chad.”
“The way things ended — I’ve had time to reconsider. And I think —” He gestured, vaguely, at her stomach, at the air, at the general direction of the last three years. “Baby and all. I’m in a different place now. I think I was —”
“I think,” Scarlett said, carefully, “that you need to —”
“I’ve missed you.” He said it with the complete confidence of a man who had never fully absorbed that the breakup was a closed door. “I think we gave up too quickly. And if you need support right now, obviously I —”
“I think you’ve met Scarlett’s boyfriend.”
The voice came from directly behind her left shoulder. She hadn’t heard him approach — she hadn’t heard anything except the internal sounds of her own astonishment — but there was a hand at the small of her back, warm and easy, and Declan Rush stepped into her peripheral vision and extended his other hand toward Chad with the pleasant, relaxed ease of a man who was entirely comfortable with where he’d arrived.
Chad shook it. Automatically. The way you shook a hand before you’d processed whose it was.
“Declan Rush.” Declan smiled — the polished version, the one from pitches and industry events, which was a cousin of his real smile but significantly more controlled. “You’re Chad? I’ve heard the name.”
Chad’s expression had cycled rapidly through three configurations. He landed on something that was trying to be confident. “I wasn’t aware Scarlett was —”
“Occupied?” Declan said. His hand was still at her back. Not pressing, just there. “Yeah. Thoroughly.”
Silence that lasted approximately one geological age.
“Right,” Chad said. “I should — good to see you, Scarlett.”
He moved away toward the other end of the bar, and Scarlett watched him go, and Declan did not move his hand.
She turned to look at him.
He was looking at the space where Chad had been, expression settling back into something she couldn’t quite read.
“Declan.”
“He was going to say he’d take you back.” The words were flat, factual, stripped of everything else. “I heard the beginning of it from fifteen feet away.”
“I know.”
“You were going to handle it.”
“I was in the middle of handling it.”
He looked at her then, and the polished expression had gone entirely. What was underneath it was less comfortable, more real — something that was making decisions about itself in real time. “I know you were,” he said. “I know that. I’m sorry I — I didn’t mean to step on it.”
“Declan.” She said it slower. “You said you were my boyfriend.”
A beat.
“Yeah.” He held her gaze. “I did.”
“In front of Chad.”
“In front of Chad.”
“Without any prior —”
“Without any prior discussion, yes.” He exhaled slowly. “I’m aware of how that was delivered.”
She looked at him for a long moment. Behind them the party moved and murmured and someone laughed too loudly at something across the room. Priya, she was aware, was approximately twelve feet away and definitely watching. She’d have questions.
Declan’s hand was still at her back.
“I’m the boyfriend,” he said. “That’s what I am. I should have — we should have had the conversation before I announced it to your ex, which was not the smoothest —”
“Declan.”
“Yeah.”
“I’m not telling you to take it back.”
Something moved across his face. She watched it carefully. He wasn’t performing anything right now — she’d seen him perform often enough to know the difference, and this wasn’t it. This was the Declan who’d sat with her in the ultrasound room and held her hand without being asked.
“We need to actually talk,” she said. “Not here. But —” She paused, working through the architecture of it, because her brain was running several calculations simultaneously and arriving at a conclusion that she was not ready to fully articulate. “You’re not wrong.”
He blinked.
“About the categories,” she said. “About what they are. I think we’ve been running an outdated framework.”
He searched her face. She made herself hold still.
“Okay,” he said.
“Don’t smile at me like that.”
“Like what?”
“Like you won something.”
“I’m just agreeing.” His smile was the real one now, the one with no armor in it. His hand was still there. “We can talk later.”
“We are going to talk later,” she confirmed.
“I’ll get you a sparkling water,” he said, “because you looked like you wanted to throw an entire glass of wine at Chad’s blazer, and I respect that, but Wren doesn’t need the secondhand stress.”
“The blazer has it coming.”
“The blazer has always had it coming.” He moved toward the bar, easy and unhurried, and she watched him go, and Priya materialized at her shoulder approximately three seconds later.
“That,” Priya said, “was extremely hot.”
“It was a miscommunication.”
“That man called himself your boyfriend in front of Chad Whitfield.”
“It was impromptu.”
“Scarlett.” Priya looked at her with the specific expression she’d been deploying since they were twenty and in the same dorm hallway. “I say this with love. Stop filing your feelings in the wrong folders.”
Declan was back, holding her sparkling water, saying something to the bartender with the easy confidence of someone who always knew what he wanted to order. He caught her eye from across the room, raised an eyebrow in a question she understood — you okay? — and she tilted her chin in an answer he’d learned to read.
She was not in the wrong folders.
She was standing at a cheese board at a birthday party and a man had just called himself her boyfriend in public and she was six months pregnant with his daughter and she was not — she was absolutely not putting this anywhere near the wrong folders.
She took a sip of her sparkling water and started planning the conversation they were going to have later.
Reader Reactions