Updated Mar 23, 2026 • ~9 min read
Chapter 7: Almost
The Harwick Academic Conference on Victorian Literature was held in Boston every year in the first week of December, and Amara had been preparing her presentation for three months.
She knew it was good. She was not prone to false modesty about her own work — she had spent too long in academic spaces where women who undersold their scholarship were taken at their word, and she had learned early to distinguish between useful humility and self-sabotage. Her paper on Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s *Aurora Leigh* as a counternarrative to the Victorian marriage plot was, by her own assessment, one of the strongest pieces of work she’d produced in five years of graduate study. Her advisor had said so. Three readers at the pre-conference workshop had said so.
She was, nonetheless, nervous on the morning of the panel.
The conference hotel was a converted Edwardian building in Back Bay, all dark wood paneling and portraits of people who had been important in fields she didn’t recognize. The graduate student panel was mid-morning in one of the smaller rooms — forty chairs, most of them full, which was more than she’d expected. She found her seat at the presenters’ table, arranged her notes, and told herself to breathe.
She found him in the audience before she meant to.
He was seated near the back — probably deliberately, she thought, so as not to create the impression that he was supervising — with his coat folded on his knee and a program in his hand that he wasn’t reading. He was looking at her. When their eyes met he looked down at the program.
She looked at her notes.
She presented.
She knew, somewhere in the first two minutes, that it was going well — the room was listening in the particular way that meant they were genuinely following, not just politely attending, and the argument built the way she’d intended, each piece clicking into place, and by the time she reached the crescendo of the paper — EBB’s assertion that the woman artist’s internal life is not a compensation for the domestic life denied to her but its own complete and sufficient world — there was a quality of attention in the room that felt like held breath.
When she finished, there was a pause before the applause, which was always the better kind.
The questions were good. She handled them — the skeptical one, the pedantic one, the one that was really a comment disguised as a question — with the focused patience she’d learned from watching good scholars navigate rooms that weren’t always fully on their side. She didn’t look at him during the Q&A. She was aware of him the way you’re aware of a candle in a dark room: not looking at it directly, but calibrating your position in space by its light.
Afterward, in the lobby, colleagues stopped her. Her advisor squeezed her arm. Two professors from institutions she recognized wanted to talk about publication. She was in the middle of a conversation with a Fordham scholar about a special issue she was editing when she felt, rather than saw, him approach and wait.
She finished the conversation. She turned.
“You were incredible,” he said.
Not *you did well* or *impressive work,* the professionally appropriate responses. *Incredible,* and said in a voice she hadn’t heard from him before — lower, more direct, the voice of a man who had been watching from the back of the room and had felt something and was not entirely in command of what came out of his mouth.
She felt it land in her chest.
“Thank you,” she said. “Your presentation this morning was impressive too. The argument about Tennyson’s *In Memoriam* and grief as cultural performance—”
“I know what my presentation was.” The corner of his mouth moved. “I’m more interested in yours. The EBB argument — the idea that creative autonomy constitutes its own form of domestic sufficiency — that’s worth pursuing. You should develop it.”
“I intend to.”
“Good.”
They drifted, somehow, toward the hotel bar, which was where the conference’s natural center of gravity had located itself in the early evening — scholars decompressing, debates continuing over wine, the social structure of the day dissolving into something more informal. Amara had a glass of red wine and he had what turned out to be bourbon, and the conference crowd moved around them in fluid constellations, and they talked.
Not about the course. Not about grading or syllabi or student engagement metrics. They talked about scholarship, about the contested borders of the Victorian period, about whether there was such a thing as a literary canon or only a series of institutional preferences that accreted over time into the appearance of inevitability. He argued one side and she argued the other and then they switched sides and argued again, because that was how both of them thought — through opposition, through the stress-testing of a position against its strongest counter.
At some point she realized she had laughed three times in twenty minutes, which was more than she usually laughed in a professional setting, and that he had laughed once, and that his once had been fully present and unguarded in a way she had not seen from him before.
The bar thinned out. Her advisor stopped to say good night and raised her eyebrows very slightly at Amara’s companion before moving on, and Amara chose not to interpret the eyebrows. The conversation shifted — less about scholarship, more about the why of it. Why they were here, in academia, in this field specifically.
“I was nine,” she said. “My mother brought home a copy of *Jane Eyre* from a library book sale. I read it in three days and then read it again and then went looking for more books by women who wrote about women as if they mattered. I never really stopped.”
“First-generation student?”
“First in my family to get a bachelor’s. First to get a master’s. My mother is—” she paused, not for the right word but for the appropriate amount of it, because there was more there than a bar conversation could contain. “She’s extraordinary. She would have been a scholar herself in a different world. She reads everything she can get her hands on.”
“Does she know what your paper was about today?”
“I sent her the abstract. She texted me three praying-hands emojis and a question about whether Aurora Leigh was a real person.” She smiled. “I told her she was real the way all great characters are real.”
He was looking at her with that particular quality of attention — the full, focused kind, the kind he usually kept aimed at books or arguments or a seminar table full of students — and it was different here, unmediated by the structures of the university, without the classroom or the office or the professional context that usually kept everything in its proper frame.
He was just a man looking at her. And she was just a person being looked at.
“I should—” she began.
“I know.” He looked away first. “It’s late.”
They stood. The bar was nearly empty. The hotel lobby, visible through the glass partition, was quiet, the Edwardian portraits watching dispassionately. He held the door open and they walked out together, and the elevator bank was around the corner, and the hallway outside it was carpeted and quiet and entirely empty.
She pressed the button for the sixth floor. He pressed five. The elevator opened and she stepped in and he stepped in and the door closed and the small space contracted around them, and she was aware — acutely, entirely, with every nerve — of how close they were. Not touching. Not even near touching. But close enough that she was conscious of the warmth of him, the particular quality of his silence.
The elevator stopped on five.
He didn’t move immediately. For a fraction of a second they were both still, the door open, the hallway beyond it empty, and she looked at him and he looked at her and the air in the elevator did something complicated and irreversible.
He stepped forward. Toward her. And she turned — toward him, to him, because she couldn’t help it and didn’t particularly want to — and for one breathless, suspended moment the space between them was nothing at all and something was about to happen that would change everything, she could feel it the way you feel weather before it breaks—
He stopped.
He took a step back. One deliberate step, back into the hallway, and his face rearranged itself into the familiar controlled mask, the professional distance, the careful architecture of a man who had been frightened back into his defenses by something he couldn’t afford to want.
“I can’t,” he said. “You’re my student.”
She felt it like a door closing. “I’m not your *student.* I’m your TA. That’s different.”
“Same power dynamic. Same ethics violation.” He was looking at a point past her shoulder. “I’m sorry, Amara.”
The elevator door started to close. She put her hand out and stopped it.
“Professor Lancaster,” she said.
He looked at her.
“Just — I know.” She let the door go. “Good night.”
The door closed. The elevator moved. She pressed her back against the wall and stared at the ceiling and breathed, very carefully, and told herself that it was fine. That nothing had happened. That she was fine.
She was not fine.
But she was also, she realized somewhere beneath the ache of it, not angry. She understood. She had understood since October, since the overheard conversation and the book left on her desk, since the moment she’d learned about Monica and realized what was underneath all that careful cold.
He was afraid.
She could be patient.
Four months.
She pressed her palm flat against the elevator wall and counted the floors and breathed and told herself: *four months.*
Reader Reactions