Updated Mar 23, 2026 • ~9 min read
Chapter 6: The wrong courtship begins
ARABELLA
The announcement appeared in the Post on a Friday morning: not an official announcement, nothing so definite — society rarely moved in official announcements until the thing was settled — but the entry in the social pages that served the same function. *Viscount Blackwood was observed at the Ashford musicale in the company of Lady Caroline Winters for the second successive engagement. Informed sources note that the pairing is very much as expected.*
She read it twice.
She set the Post beside the toast rack. She picked up her tea.
Her aunt was watching her over the rim of her own cup with the expression she used when she was waiting for Arabella to say something.
“It’s expected,” Arabella said. “She’s beautiful, she’s well-connected, and she’s been angling for him since the moment he returned. Of course the papers have noticed.”
“And what do you think?” her aunt said.
She thought several things. She thought them in sequence and with the precision she brought to problems that required careful navigation, and she recognised that at least half of what she was thinking was feeling rather than thought, which was inconvenient, because she was better at the thought half.
“I think,” she said, “that he does not know that Lady Caroline Winters is about to become his apparent intended while he is legally married to me.” She drank her tea. “He should be told.”
“Yes,” her aunt said.
“I also think,” she said, and then stopped, because this was the part she had less precision about.
“Yes?” her aunt said.
“I think I should have told him everything when he came on Tuesday evening instead of only the facts.”
Her aunt said nothing, which was her most effective conversational move.
Arabella folded the Post with more precision than was necessary and went upstairs to write a letter.
She did not send the letter.
She wrote it with her usual exactitude — the situation, the newspaper entry, the facts of his position — and she read it back and found that it was entirely correct and entirely wrong, that it said everything except the one thing that mattered, which was that she had been in the British Museum reading room on Thursday and he had sat across the table and found an error in a periodical and she had not wanted to leave.
This was not a thing she could put in a letter. She folded it and put it in the drawer.
He would discover the newspaper item himself. He would deal with it as he dealt with things: with the particular, assembled precision of a man who had learned to take the world apart and examine the pieces because he could not feel the whole of it from the inside.
She went to the reading room on Thursday. She had told herself she would not, and then told herself not to be ridiculous — she went on Thursdays, she had always gone on Thursdays, she was not going to alter her own patterns because a man had walked past the window once.
He was not there.
She settled with some relief and worked for an hour with excellent concentration before the door opened and he arrived, coat damp from the brief rain outside, the expression of a man who had been somewhere he needed to be first and had come here second.
“You came,” she said.
“I said I would remember,” he said.
He sat across from her and took a periodical from the stack and they worked for twenty minutes in the focused quiet that was becoming, she thought, a thing. A specific thing with a specific texture. She had not had a thing with a texture before. She was not accustomed to this.
He said: “You saw the Post.”
She looked up. He was looking at the page, not at her.
“Yes,” she said.
“Caroline Winters and I are not — there’s nothing formal. My mother considers it a suitable match and the papers have made their assumption, but I have not—” He paused. He turned a page. “I have not done anything to address it.”
“You should,” she said. “Because of the situation.”
He looked at her then. “What does the situation require?”
She put down her periodical. This was the conversation she had been preparing for and avoiding in equal measure for the past ten days.
“Lord Blackwood,” she said.
“Sebastian,” he said. “Under the circumstances.”
She absorbed this. “The situation requires,” she said, “that you make a decision about the marriage. You have several options. Dissolution — it would be manageable, I believe, given the lack of consummation and the years of effective abandonment, though it would require some care about how it was presented. Acknowledgment — public acknowledgment, which would end the question of Lady Caroline but would also change my position considerably, and your own, and would require—” she stopped.
“What?”
She chose her words. “It would require us to decide what we actually are,” she said. “Which we have not done.”
He was very quiet. “No,” he said. “We haven’t.”
“I’m not asking you to decide now,” she said. “I am telling you that the paper’s item makes a timeline necessary. If you are going to — if Lady Caroline Winters continues to believe there is an understanding—”
“There is no understanding,” he said. “I will make that clear.”
“You should also,” she said carefully, “consider what you are making clear to her in its place.”
He looked at her. Something moved behind the focused expression — the further thing, the quality she had started to think of as the real conversation beneath the conversation he was having aloud.
“You think I should court you,” he said.
“I think,” she said precisely, “that you should determine what you want and then do it. Whatever it is.” She held his gaze. “I am not—” she stopped again, which was happening more than she liked. “I spent eight years being managed around rather than told things directly,” she said. “I would prefer directness, whatever the directness is.”
He held her gaze for a moment. “Dissolution is not what I want,” he said. Directly. As requested.
She felt something in her chest that she did not examine. “Then what do you want?”
“I want to know you,” he said. “Properly. As though we have just met, because for my part we have.” He looked at the table. “I know that is not — I know there is a history here that isn’t mine, because I lost it. I know you have been carrying eight years of something I can’t access. I am not asking you to pretend that isn’t the case.” He looked up. “I’m asking you to let me start from here.”
She sat with that.
She thought about the church at two in the morning and the seven years of managing and the particular freedom of being nobody’s wife in practice, only in certificate, which had been a kind of safety she had not known she would need until she needed it, and now he was here and he was asking to start from here and she did not know what to do with the feeling that produced.
“That seems,” she said, “like the right approach.”
He exhaled. She had not quite realised he’d been holding anything.
“Lady Caroline will be managed,” he said.
“I know,” she said. She believed him.
“I should call on your aunt,” he said. “Formally. To begin properly.”
“She knows who you are,” Arabella said.
“I expect she has significant opinions about me.”
“Significant and not entirely favourable.”
“I would expect nothing less,” he said. He looked at her with the thing that was almost a smile. “I’ll bring flowers.”
“She doesn’t like flowers,” Arabella said. “She finds them ostentatious. Bring books.”
He looked at her. “What kind?”
“She is currently reading Cicero and has recently expressed dissatisfaction with the available translations.”
He nodded. He made a small note in the margin of his periodical, which she thought was charming in a way she was not ready to admit.
“Thursday,” he said.
“Tuesday and Thursday,” she said.
He left before she did — a meeting, he said, which she didn’t ask about — and she sat in the reading room after he’d gone with the particular sensation of a woman who had just agreed to something she had been preparing not to agree to, and who found, somewhat to her own surprise, that she did not regret it.
She thought: this is either the most reasonable decision I have ever made or the most foolish.
She thought: possibly both.
She gathered her things and went home and found she could not settle to anything for the rest of the afternoon, and she had a letter to write to her father’s old friend about a philosophical matter, and she wrote the first three sentences four separate times and got them wrong each time, and she finally put her pen down and admitted to herself, in the private court where she managed all the things she did not say aloud, that she was in some amount of trouble.
She had been married to a man for eight years and he had come back and looked at her with nothing in his eyes, which had been the specific, private grief she’d anticipated.
What she had not anticipated was that she would sit across a table from him twice a week and find that the nothing in his eyes was becoming something, slowly, the way light changed in a room when clouds moved past the window — not an event, not a moment, just the gradual alteration of a quality, until the room was different than it had been and there was no single point at which the change had happened.
She picked up her pen and wrote the letter to her father’s friend.
She did not write well for the rest of the day.
Reader Reactions