Updated Apr 19, 2026 • ~13 min read
Chapter 10: Quinn’s Backstory
Quinn
Quinn finds herself sitting in Mabel’s Diner at two in the afternoon on a Wednesday, picking at a piece of apple pie she doesn’t really want while trying to explain to someone who’s somehow become an unexpected friend why Asher Brooks running away from a flour fight has left her feeling more hurt than she has any right to be.
“He just left,” Quinn says for the third time, stabbing her fork into the pie with more force than necessary. “One minute we were laughing and covered in flour and having fun, and the next minute he looked terrified and bolted like the bakery was on fire. I don’t understand what I did wrong.”
Mabel refills Quinn’s coffee with the practiced efficiency of someone who’s been running a diner for forty years and has heard approximately every relationship problem that exists.
“You didn’t do anything wrong, honey,” Mabel says gently, sliding into the booth across from Quinn. “Asher’s been alone for two years. He’s built walls that make Fort Knox look accessible. What you did was make him feel something he hasn’t felt since Emma died, and that terrified him.”
“But I wasn’t trying to make him feel anything,” Quinn protests. “We were just baking cookies with Ruby. It was innocent. Neighborly. Nothing threatening about a flour fight.”
“Except it wasn’t just baking cookies,” Mabel points out with the bluntness that Quinn’s come to expect from her. “It was domestic and warm and exactly what family looks like, and Asher hasn’t had that in two years. He hasn’t let himself have it because he’s terrified of losing it again. So when he felt it with you and Ruby, he panicked and ran.”
Quinn knows Mabel is probably right—knows that Asher’s abrupt departure was about his own fear rather than anything Quinn did—but it still hurts in a way she doesn’t want to examine too closely.
“I shouldn’t care this much,” Quinn admits quietly. “I’ve only been here six weeks. I barely know him. I’m supposed to be focusing on the bakery and staying away from relationships. But somehow I’m sitting here upset because my grumpy neighbor ran away from cookie decorating.”
“You like him,” Mabel observes with a knowing smile. “And probably more than just like him, based on how hurt you look right now.”
Quinn wants to deny this, wants to insist that she’s not interested in Asher beyond friendly neighbor concern, but sitting across from Mabel who sees everything and has clearly decided that honesty is the best policy, Quinn finds herself admitting the truth she’s been avoiding.
“I might like him a little,” Quinn concedes. “But that’s a terrible idea for approximately twelve reasons.”
“Name them,” Mabel challenges, settling in like she’s prepared to debate each point.
“First, I just got out of a relationship where my fiancé cheated on me,” Quinn says, ticking off on her fingers. “Second, I moved here specifically to avoid men and relationships. Third, Asher is clearly not over his wife. Fourth, he obviously doesn’t want to be involved with anyone based on the running away thing. Fifth—”
“Let’s pause on reason number one,” Mabel interrupts. “Tell me about the fiancé. You’ve mentioned him before but never the full story.”
Quinn sighs, because talking about Marcus still makes her chest tight even though she’s mostly over the heartbreak and firmly settled in the anger stage of grief.
“His name was Marcus,” Quinn starts, staring at her coffee instead of meeting Mabel’s eyes. “We were together for five years. Engaged for one. The wedding was planned for last summer—big fancy Manhattan wedding, two hundred guests, venue booked a year in advance.”
“What happened?” Mabel asks gently.
“I found him in bed with his coworker one week before the wedding,” Quinn says flatly, and even now the memory makes her stomach twist. “I went to his apartment to surprise him with the finalized seating chart, and instead I got surprised with the very visual confirmation that Sarah from accounting was more than ‘just a friend from work’ like he’d always claimed.”
Mabel makes a sympathetic sound, and Quinn continues before she can lose her nerve.
“The worst part wasn’t even the cheating, though that was awful,” Quinn admits. “It was that he tried to convince me to marry him anyway. Said it was a mistake, said it didn’t mean anything, said we’d already paid for the venue and his parents were flying in from California and couldn’t we just get through the wedding and deal with this later?”
“Please tell me you didn’t consider it,” Mabel says with horror.
“I threw my engagement ring at his head and walked out,” Quinn confirms. “Called off the wedding, lost all the deposits, endured approximately eight hundred awkward conversations explaining why the wedding was canceled without explaining what Marcus did because his family is socially prominent and I didn’t want the drama.”
“You’re nicer than I would have been,” Mabel observes. “I would’ve taken out a billboard in Times Square.”
Quinn laughs despite herself, because the image of Marcus’s infidelity announced in massive lettering is actually appealing.
“I thought about it,” Quinn admits. “But mostly I just wanted to escape. The city felt suffocating—everywhere I went reminded me of Marcus, of our relationship, of the life I’d planned that turned out to be built on lies. So when Aunt Claire died and left me the bakery, it felt like the universe providing an exit strategy.”
“And you ran here to start over,” Mabel finishes.
“And I ran here to start over,” Quinn confirms. “Determined to focus on the bakery, build a life that’s just mine, never trust a man again because apparently my judgment is terrible and I can’t tell the difference between genuine love and a man who’s just comfortable with our relationship while sleeping with someone else.”
“Marcus was an idiot,” Mabel says firmly. “And what he did says everything about his character and nothing about your judgment. You can’t protect yourself from liars by never trusting anyone. You just end up alone and bitter.”
“Alone seems safer,” Quinn argues. “Alone means I can’t get hurt again.”
“Alone also means you miss out on the good stuff,” Mabel counters. “Like flour fights with handsome firefighters and their adorable daughters. Like building real connections with people who actually care about you. Like taking a risk on someone who might actually be worth it.”
“Asher ran away from me,” Quinn points out. “That doesn’t exactly scream ‘worth the risk.'”
“Asher ran away from his own feelings,” Mabel corrects. “Not from you. There’s a difference. He’s scared, not disinterested. And I’ve known that man for ten years—since before he met Emma, through their marriage, through her death, through the last two years of him being a ghost of himself. These past six weeks since you arrived, I’ve seen him actually smile. I’ve seen him engage with the town instead of hiding from it. I’ve seen him less alone and more alive. You’re good for him, honey. Even if he’s too scared to admit it.”
“I don’t want to be good for someone,” Quinn says quietly. “I want to be good for myself. I spent five years trying to be what Marcus wanted, trying to be the perfect girlfriend and then fiancée, trying to make our relationship work even when I felt him pulling away. I don’t want to do that again—sacrifice myself for someone who might not even want me.”
“That’s not what I’m suggesting,” Mabel says. “I’m suggesting you stop protecting yourself from every possible connection and consider that maybe, just maybe, Asher Brooks is nothing like Marcus. Maybe his loyalty and fear and devotion to his daughter actually make him more trustworthy, not less. Maybe running away from feelings he wasn’t ready for shows integrity rather than weakness.”
“Or maybe he’s just not interested and I’m reading too much into neighborly interactions,” Quinn argues.
“Sure, honey,” Mabel says with that knowing smile. “Sure. That’s definitely what’s happening. The man who watches you through his window when you’re teaching Ruby, who fixed your pipes without being asked, who admitted out loud that he wants you at dinner, who looked at you during that flour fight like you were the sun and he’d forgotten what warmth felt like—that man is definitely not interested.”
Quinn stares at Mabel, because she wasn’t aware that her feelings and Asher’s possible feelings were this transparent to outside observers.
“The whole town is watching us, aren’t they?” Quinn asks with dawning horror.
“Obsessively,” Mabel confirms cheerfully. “Judy has a literal clipboard with progress updates. We’re all invested. You’re our favorite romance in years.”
“That’s deeply disturbing,” Quinn says, but she’s also kind of touched in a weird way that an entire town cares enough about her happiness to actively scheme for it.
“Welcome to Maplewood,” Mabel says with a shrug. “We meddle because we care. And speaking as someone who’s watched you these past six weeks, you’re different here than when you first arrived. Lighter. More settled. Like you’re actually building a life instead of just hiding from your old one.”
Quinn wants to deny this, but Mabel’s right—the bakery is thriving, she’s made actual friends, she wakes up excited about her day instead of dreading it, and somewhere along the way Maplewood stopped feeling like an escape plan and started feeling like home.
“I don’t trust easily anymore,” Quinn admits quietly, voicing the fear that’s been holding her back from even considering a relationship with Asher or anyone else. “Marcus destroyed that. And I’m terrified of making the same mistake again—trusting someone who seems good and loyal and genuine, only to find out I was wrong.”
“Asher’s not like city boys,” Mabel says firmly. “He’s loyal to a fault. When he commits, he commits completely—you saw that with Emma, how devastated he was when she died, how he still can’t quite move on because he loved her that deeply. That kind of loyalty doesn’t just disappear. If Asher ever lets himself love again, whoever gets his heart will have it completely and forever.”
“That’s terrifying,” Quinn whispers, because that level of devotion sounds both wonderful and overwhelming.
“It’s terrifying and beautiful,” Mabel agrees. “Just like anything worth having. The question is: are you brave enough to take the risk?”
Quinn doesn’t have an answer for that, so she goes back to picking at her pie while Mabel watches with patient understanding.
“I’m not saying you need to decide anything right now,” Mabel says eventually. “I’m just saying don’t write off Asher because he got scared and ran. Give him time to work through whatever panic he’s dealing with. Keep being yourself. Keep teaching Ruby. Keep being a good neighbor. And if something more develops naturally, let it. Don’t fight it just because you’re scared of being hurt again.”
“I’m not interested in Asher—” Quinn starts, but even she can hear how weak it sounds.
“Sure, honey,” Mabel says with that infuriating knowing smile. “Sure.”
Quinn leaves the diner an hour later with a full stomach, slightly better emotional state, and the uncomfortable awareness that maybe, possibly, she’s a little bit interested in her grumpy neighbor despite every logical reason she has for avoiding relationships.
She’s not ready to do anything about it.
Not ready to risk her heart on someone who might not want it.
Not ready to believe that what she feels in those rare unguarded moments with Asher is real and mutual and worth pursuing.
But walking back to her bakery through the fall afternoon with the town bustling around her and her new life solid beneath her feet, Quinn admits something to herself that she’s been avoiding for weeks.
Asher Brooks is nothing like Marcus.
Where Marcus was smooth and charming and ultimately dishonest, Asher is gruff and awkward and painfully genuine.
Where Marcus talked constantly about his feelings while apparently having none, Asher rarely talks about emotions but feels everything deeply.
Where Marcus was comfortable with their relationship while actively betraying it, Asher runs away from connection because he feels it too much and it terrifies him.
And maybe, just maybe, being terrified of feelings because they’re real and intense is significantly better than being comfortable with feelings that are shallow and false.
Quinn doesn’t know if anything will happen with Asher.
Doesn’t know if he’ll ever work through his grief and fear enough to risk a relationship.
Doesn’t know if she’s brave enough to trust someone with her heart after Marcus destroyed it so thoroughly.
But for the first time since moving to Maplewood, Quinn considers the possibility that maybe she wants to find out.
That night, when Ruby shows up at the bakery with a drawing labeled “I’m sorry Daddy got scared” featuring stick figures covered in flour and hearts everywhere, Quinn accepts it with tears in her eyes and promises Ruby that everything is okay, that grown-ups sometimes get overwhelmed, that her daddy isn’t in trouble and neither is Quinn.
“Do you still like Daddy?” Ruby asks with six-year-old directness. “Even though he ran away?”
Quinn looks at this sweet child who’s somehow worked her way into Quinn’s heart despite every wall Quinn built, and she answers honestly.
“I still like your daddy,” Quinn confirms. “And I really like you, Ruby-roo.”
“Good,” Ruby says with satisfaction. “‘Cause I like you too. And I think Daddy does too, even though he got scared. Uncle Cole says Daddy’s bad at feelings but that doesn’t mean he doesn’t have them.”
Quinn laughs because Uncle Cole is apparently extremely perceptive, and she sends Ruby home with cookies and a hug and the hope that maybe, eventually, Asher will figure out how to stop running from feelings that might actually be worth having.
And when she sees the lights on in Asher’s house later that evening, she doesn’t analyze what it means that she notices, or that she cares, or that she finds herself hoping he’s okay even though he hurt her by running.
Because maybe Mabel is right.
Maybe being scared of real feelings is better than being comfortable with false ones.
And maybe, just maybe, Quinn is brave enough to wait and see if Asher Brooks can figure out how to stop running long enough to realize what’s right in front of him.
Even if waiting terrifies her almost as much as the possibility of trying.
Reader Reactions