Updated Apr 19, 2026 • ~13 min read
Chapter 11: Town Scheme #3 – Locked in
Quinn
Quinn volunteers to help set up for the charity event at the community church on a Thursday evening two weeks after the flour fight incident, mostly because staying busy keeps her from overthinking the complicated situation with Asher—who’s been polite but distant since he ran away from baking lessons, clearly maintaining careful boundaries that Quinn should appreciate but actually just finds frustrating.
The church basement is cluttered with folding tables and boxes of donated items for the charity auction, and Pastor David greets Quinn at the door with his usual friendly smile and a clipboard listing setup tasks.
“Thank you for helping,” Pastor David says, checking her name off his volunteer list. “We’ve got about twenty people coming tonight to get everything organized before Saturday’s event. You’ll be working on sorting and pricing donated items—Asher’s down there already starting on the furniture.”
Quinn’s heart does an uncomfortable skip at Asher’s name, and she considers making an excuse about suddenly remembering another commitment, but Pastor David is already gesturing her toward the basement stairs and she doesn’t want to seem like she’s avoiding Asher even though that’s exactly what she’s doing.
The basement is exactly what Quinn expects from a small-town church—low ceilings, fluorescent lighting, concrete floors, and the lingering smell of old hymnals and potluck dinners. Asher is indeed already there, moving a donated couch against the far wall with the kind of effortless strength that Quinn definitely doesn’t notice because she’s focused on being professional and neighborly.
“Quinn,” Asher says when he spots her, and there’s surprise and something else—possibly dismay—in his voice. “I didn’t know you were volunteering tonight.”
“Pastor David asked,” Quinn says, setting her bag on one of the folding tables and trying to project casual friendliness rather than the awkward tension she actually feels. “Said you needed help sorting donations.”
“Right,” Asher says, and he’s already turning back to the furniture like this conversation is painful. “There are boxes of kitchen stuff over there that need pricing. I’ll handle the furniture.”
So they’re doing this—working in the same space while pretending they’re not both hyperaware of each other’s presence, maintaining the careful distance Asher clearly wants even though it makes Quinn want to scream with frustration.
Quinn starts sorting through boxes of donated kitchen items—mismatched plates, ancient coffee makers, the kind of random household goods that accumulate in church basements—and tries not to watch Asher moving furniture across the room, tries not to remember how he looked covered in flour and almost smiling, tries not to feel hurt by how hard he’s working to avoid her.
They work in silence for maybe twenty minutes, the only sounds the scraping of furniture and Quinn’s pricing gun clicking, and the awkwardness is so thick Quinn could cut it with one of the donated butter knives she’s currently trying to value.
She’s about to break the silence with some inane comment about the weather when she hears footsteps on the stairs—multiple people coming down—and then Mayor Judy’s voice calling out cheerfully.
“Quinn! Asher! Change of plans!”
Quinn looks up to see Judy standing at the bottom of the stairs with approximately ten other volunteers crowding behind her, all wearing expressions that Quinn has learned to recognize as “we’re about to do something manipulative but well-intentioned.”
“What kind of change?” Asher asks suspiciously, setting down the lamp he was moving.
“We realized we have too many volunteers for the space,” Judy announces with the kind of confidence that suggests this is absolutely not a sudden realization. “So we’re going to split up—half of us will work on the auction setup at the town hall instead. You two can finish here and lock up when you’re done!”
“I can help at the town hall—” Quinn starts, already seeing where this is going.
“No need!” Judy says brightly. “You’ve already started down here. Just finish up the sorting and pricing, lock the basement door when you leave—key’s on the table—and we’ll see you Saturday!”
The volunteers swarm back up the stairs with suspicious efficiency, and Quinn hears the basement door close with a firm click that sounds significantly more final than it should.
“That was weird,” Quinn observes, walking toward the stairs.
“That was a setup,” Asher says grimly, already ahead of her and trying the door handle.
It doesn’t budge.
“We’re stuck?!” Quinn asks, joining Asher at the door and pulling on the handle herself with the same unsuccessful result.
“Apparently,” Asher says, and he’s examining the door with professional attention. “The lock mechanism is jammed. Or more likely, taped from the outside so it won’t open from this side.”
“They locked us in on purpose?” Quinn’s voice comes out higher than intended, because even though she’s come to expect meddling from Maplewood, deliberately trapping people in a church basement seems extreme even for Judy.
“Definitely on purpose,” Asher confirms, pulling out his phone. “I’ll call someone—”
He pauses, staring at his phone screen with growing frustration.
“No service?” Quinn guesses, checking her own phone and finding the same problem—zero bars, no connection, the basement apparently serving as a perfect cell phone dead zone.
“No service,” Asher confirms. “We’re in a concrete basement. Of course there’s no service.”
They both stand there for a moment, processing the situation—trapped in a church basement together with no way to call for help and presumably no rescue coming until someone “discovers” them in however many hours Judy has decided is appropriate for forced emotional intimacy.
“How long do you think they’ll leave us here?” Quinn asks, leaning against the wall and trying to find humor in the absurdity rather than panic about being trapped.
“Three hours minimum,” Asher says, checking his watch. “Long enough for us to run out of small talk and be forced into actual conversation. That’s usually how these schemes work.”
“You sound experienced with being manipulated by the town,” Quinn observes.
“They tried to set me up with approximately six different women in the year after Emma died,” Asher admits, sliding down the wall to sit on the floor with his back against the concrete. “Judy’s tactics have only gotten more aggressive with time.”
Quinn sits down next to him—maintaining a careful distance but close enough that they can talk without shouting across the basement—and decides that if they’re going to be trapped here for hours, they might as well stop being awkward about the elephant in the room.
“About the flour fight,” Quinn starts. “And you running away. I’m sorry if I pushed too hard. I know you’re not looking for—”
“You didn’t push anything,” Asher interrupts, and his voice is rough with something that might be regret. “I panicked. That’s on me, not you.”
“Why?” Quinn asks gently. “What made you panic?”
Asher is quiet for long enough that Quinn thinks he’s not going to answer, and then he starts talking—slow and halting like the words are being pulled from somewhere deep.
“It felt like family,” Asher says quietly. “The three of us making cookies, laughing, covered in flour. It felt exactly like what family is supposed to feel like. And I haven’t felt that since Emma died.”
Quinn’s heart aches at the pain in his voice, and she waits silently for him to continue.
“Emma was my wife,” Asher says, and Quinn can hear the love and loss wrapped up in those words. “We met in college, got married young, had Ruby three years into our marriage. She was… everything. Smart and funny and completely in love with being a mother. She made our house feel like home.”
“What happened?” Quinn asks softly, even though Pastor David mentioned something about his wife at the town meeting.
“Car accident,” Asher says flatly. “Two years ago. Drunk driver ran a red light, hit her car on the driver’s side. She died instantly. Ruby was home with me. She was four years old, and suddenly she didn’t have a mother anymore.”
“I’m sorry,” Quinn says, and the words feel inadequate but genuine. “That’s devastating. For both of you.”
“Ruby barely remembers her,” Asher continues, and there’s something broken in how he says it. “I don’t know if that’s better or worse. Better because she’s not actively grieving someone she remembers clearly? Or worse because she’s losing the memory of her own mother?”
“Both,” Quinn says honestly. “It’s probably both. Grief doesn’t follow logic.”
Asher looks at her with those grey eyes that seem to see too much, and Quinn sees raw vulnerability that he usually keeps hidden behind grumpiness and walls.
“The flour fight felt like what Ruby’s been missing,” Asher admits. “Female presence. Gentle teaching. Someone who makes domestic moments feel warm instead of just functional. And I wanted it so badly—wanted you there, wanted that family feeling, wanted Ruby to have what she’s been lacking. But wanting it terrified me because Emma died and people leave and I can’t survive losing someone else.”
Quinn understands completely—understands the fear of risking your heart after catastrophic loss, understands building walls to protect yourself from future pain, understands choosing isolation over the possibility of being hurt again.
“I get it,” Quinn says quietly. “My ex-fiancé cheated on me one week before our wedding.”
Asher turns to look at her fully, surprise and anger flickering across his face.
“Marcus,” Quinn continues, finding it easier to talk in this concrete basement with Asher than she expected. “We were together five years, engaged for one, wedding planned down to the last detail. I found him in bed with his coworker who he always said was ‘just a friend.’ He tried to convince me to marry him anyway because we’d already paid for the venue.”
“He’s an idiot,” Asher says with feeling. “Anyone who’d cheat on you—”
He stops abruptly, seeming to realize that this is the first real compliment he’s given Quinn, and she can see him processing whether acknowledging attraction makes this whole situation more complicated.
“Thank you,” Quinn says, accepting the compliment warmly. “But my point is, I understand being scared to trust again. Marcus destroyed my ability to believe people when they say they love me. I moved here specifically to avoid relationships, to build a life that’s just mine, to never risk my heart again.”
“So we’re both disasters,” Asher observes with something that might be dark humor.
“Completely,” Quinn agrees. “You’re running from feelings because you lost someone you loved. I’m running from feelings because I trusted someone who betrayed me. We’re perfect examples of how grief and heartbreak make people do stupid things like avoid connection.”
“Is that what we’re doing?” Asher asks. “Avoiding connection?”
“You ran away from a flour fight,” Quinn points out. “I’ve been telling myself for weeks that I’m definitely not interested in my grumpy neighbor despite evidence to the contrary. So yes, I’d say we’re both avoiding connection pretty aggressively.”
Asher laughs—an actual genuine laugh that Quinn’s only heard a few times—and the sound transforms his face into something that makes her heart skip.
“We’re idiots,” he says.
“Complete idiots,” Quinn agrees.
They sit in comfortable silence for a while, the awkwardness from earlier dissipating into something warmer and more honest, and Quinn realizes that Judy’s scheme—while manipulative and boundary-violating—is actually working because Quinn’s learning more about Asher in this trapped conversation than she has in two months of carefully maintained distance.
“Tell me about Emma,” Quinn says eventually. “Not how she died, but who she was. What made her special.”
Asher’s expression softens, and he talks—about meeting Emma in a college chemistry class, about her terrible sense of direction that meant she got lost even with GPS, about how she cried at every movie including comedies, about her determination to make their house a home even when money was tight.
And Quinn listens, understanding that this is Asher letting her in—trusting her with his grief, his memories, his fear of moving on while still honoring his past.
When he’s done, Quinn shares about Marcus—the good parts before the cheating, the plans they made, the life she thought they were building together. She talks about the heartbreak and anger and the slow realization that maybe Marcus was never who she thought he was, that maybe she loved the idea of him more than the reality.
“You’re nothing like him,” Quinn says eventually. “Marcus was smooth and charming and ultimately dishonest. You’re gruff and awkward and painfully genuine. That’s why you scare me—because you’re real in a way he never was.”
“You scare me too,” Asher admits. “Because wanting you feels dangerous. Letting Ruby get attached feels dangerous. Building something real feels dangerous when I know how completely devastating loss can be.”
“So what do we do?” Quinn asks. “Keep avoiding each other? Keep pretending we don’t feel whatever this is?”
“Probably,” Asher says, but he’s smiling slightly. “That’s the safe choice.”
“Or?” Quinn prompts.
“Or we acknowledge that we’re both disasters with damage and baggage, and maybe that makes us perfect for each other because we both understand being scared,” Asher says slowly. “We take it slow. We’re honest about the fear. We don’t push for more than we’re ready for.”
“That sounds terrifying and reasonable,” Quinn says.
“Welcome to adult relationships,” Asher responds. “Terrifying and reasonable in equal measure.”
The basement door opens approximately two and a half hours after they were locked in—Sheriff Hank “discovering” them with theatrical surprise—and Quinn and Asher climb the stairs to find the entire volunteer crew waiting with barely suppressed grins.
“Thank goodness we found you!” Judy says with absolutely no shame. “The door must have jammed!”
“The door was taped shut,” Asher says flatly, holding up the piece of duct tape he removed from the lock mechanism on his way out.
“How odd,” Judy says innocently. “Well, you’re free now! Did you have a nice… chat?”
Quinn catches Asher’s eye, and something passes between them—understanding, humor, tentative hope—and she finds herself smiling despite the absurdity.
“We talked,” Quinn confirms. “Thank you for the forced proximity, Judy. Very subtle.”
“I don’t know what you mean,” Judy says, but she’s grinning triumphantly. “See you both at the charity event Saturday!”
Walking back to their houses later—side by side instead of carefully distanced—Quinn feels something shift between them.
They’re still scared.
Still carrying damage from their pasts.
Still not sure exactly what they’re doing or where this is going.
But maybe, just maybe, being scared together is better than being safe alone.
And when Asher’s hand brushes against hers in the darkness and then deliberately tangles their fingers together, Quinn squeezes back and thinks that Judy’s meddling might actually be the best worst thing that’s ever happened to them.
“This is crazy,” Asher mutters, but he doesn’t let go of her hand.
“Completely,” Quinn agrees. “But maybe good crazy instead of bad crazy?”
“Maybe,” Asher says, and he’s almost smiling.
And Quinn thinks that maybe—just maybe—they’re going to be okay.
Whatever this is, whoever they become together, it’s worth the risk of trying.
Even if the entire town is definitely watching and definitely adding this to their matchmaking scoreboard.
Reader Reactions